Should there be secular music in church? This is a non-issue with some people, and a barn burner for others...so here goes.
First, you have to consider what is secular and what is spiritual. I'm not a big fan of labels in general, and especially when it comes to music. But there cannot be any such thing as Christian music, because music is amoral. It's neither good nor bad...it's sounds, notes, measures, rests and rythym. You can only have Christian musicians or Christian lyrics, but not Christian music.
Secondly, there is a misconception among some very conservative Christians that the only truth out there is found in the Bible. This is just not true. There are a lot of subjects that the Bible doesn't address that are nonetheless true. I've never read much math or US history in the Bible, but there are truths there. The Bible is not a monopoly on truth. Now, it's is truth from God, and it's important, and it's eternally important. Science, philosophy and even music may contain truth or pose questions of humanity that are worth looking at.
What kind of music did David play on his harp to soothe Saul? Who knows? On the issue of using "secular" music in church, the Bible is silent. But if you don't have a problem using secular illustrations, or personal stories, or facts from history or business, or jokes you heard from a friend, then there isn't much difference in using a secular song. None of that is strictly Biblical. They are all tools. Paul used the philosophy and writers of the day to communicate with the Romans on Mars Hill. Musicians and movie makers are philosophers of our day.
In the most recent Simply Strategic Show episode, Tony and Tim make two excellent points about their use of music at Granger. They remind listenrs that the music never stands alone...it's part of an entire service. And they say that sometimes, music is used to raise questions.
Objectors to this approach sometimes say things like, "well, if you're using secular music to reach secular people, will you pass out crack to reach drug addicts." They mention people like Madonna. These are obviously extreme examples, and the equivilent of throwing out the baby with the bath water. Paul said he would become like a Jew to reach the Jew or like a Gentile to reach the Gentile. I can assume because he was a man of wisdom that he would not have become like a murderer to reach murderers. There's a Godly wisdom and discernment that's required here. There's leadership principles involved here. We can't be reckless, but we need to be relevant.
There's another argument that secular music is just not okay for church. I imagine people turning off the world on their radio before heading to church. I have a huge problem with this thought because we should be the same everywhere we go. If it's not okay to do at church, it's not okay for your life. We teach this to people all the time. Our lives should be the same on Friday night as it is on Sunday morning. We're not talking about tabernacles or temples...our bodies are the temples of God. The buildings we meet in for church on Sunday are just man-made structures.
I've heard this one too: it should sound like Christian music or church music. Now that's a really wide statement. Exactly what does Christian music sound like? Organs and keyboards and choirs? I don't think David had an organ. And I don't think they sell a lot of organ mucis CD's today in the stores. Music styles change from generation to generation. There nothing wrong with any particular style of music.
People today get their views of God from music, television and movies. Music is a powerful and emotional that can communicate in ways that words alone never can. We can shut off from it or we can use it as a tool. Obviously, there are offensive lyrics that should not be heard in church. But those should not be heard in life either.
There are a lot of grey lines here. Many Christian songs may be performed by Christians but are published and recorded by secular companies only interested in the cash. Some music labeled as Christian has little to do with God. Some secular music is very spiritual. Some worship music is not very worshipful. Many of the hymns of old were just bar tunes with new lyrics. What about instrumental music or classical music? I don't think we can get too caught up in the labels.
And I don't think a song has to be about God to be enjoyable. Teach your kids the ABC song or about wheels on a bus...those are not Christian tunes. Play a love song for your wife. It will make her smile. Do the chicken dance at a wedding...have a good time. Do the YMCA at a football game if you want. There's nothing spiritual there, but it's all okay. Some songs are there to entertain, some songs are there to make people cry, some songs are there to make you think, some songs are there to help you worship God.
I listen to all kinds of stuff (because I'm a wanna be rock star). I like popular stuff, piano music, worship music, some hymns, and the occasional country song. I've got Goo Goo Dolls, Hillsong, Tim McGraw, Daniel Powter, Mercy Me and about 500 other people on my iPod. I like it all. I like music that most normal human beings like.
If you come to Oak Leaf, you're not going to hear any Madonna of Fifty Cent songs, but you're going to hear music that sounds like music of today. You're going to hear music that sounds like the radio from people that look like musicians and love God with all their heart.